top of page
From solo therapists to group practices, we provide scalable billing solutions for mental health professionals

Are Insurance Companies Underpaying Your Practice?

8 hours ago
6 min read


Underpayment is the quiet difference between the rate your contract promises and the amount that actually lands in your account. The claim shows paid, your reports look healthy, and the shortfall repeats week after week until somebody sets the payment next to the contracted rate and sees it.
Paid is not the same as paid correctly. A contract rate of $96.95 next to a remittance payment of $84.44, a gap of $12.51 per session.

It happens in practice after practice, and it looks like nothing at all. The check is deposited, the claim is marked paid, and everybody moves on to the next fire. Nobody opens the remittance to see whether the payer paid the number in the contract, which is kind of crazy when you think about it, because that number is the whole agreement. You signed for a rate. The payer owes you that rate, not a quiet discount you never agreed to.


This article shows you two things:

  • How to run the rate check that finds underpayment in your own numbers

  • What to do with a payer once the check proves it is paying you short


What is insurance underpayment?

Insurance underpayment is what happens when a payer pays your claim below the rate written into your signed contract. The claim is not denied, and that is exactly what makes it dangerous. It is paid, just paid wrong. Think of it as an unseen wound. It bleeds quietly in the background, a little on every claim, and unless you go looking for it you will never know it is there.


A denial at least has the decency to demand your attention. An underpayment asks for none, so it runs for months while everyone assumes the money is fine.


How do you know if a payer is underpaying you?

You find it the simple way, by comparing what the payer paid against what your contract says it should have paid. Start measuring. Pull your top five payers and your top ten billing codes, and lay the paid amount beside the contracted rate for each one.


Those ten codes normally carry about 80% of everything you bill, so a payer that has drifted off contract cannot hide for long. Read the remittance closely while you are in there, especially the negative lines and the adjustments that mark underpricing. When the allowed amount sits below your contracted rate, the payer made the error, not your biller.


Take Sam, who owns a practice in Nevada. His contract paid about $96.95 for his main session code, but his remittances were paying $84.44, a gap of $12.51 on every single session. Nothing was denied. Nothing looked broken. The money was simply leaving, session by session, inside claims his reports showed as paid.

His contract paid about $96.95. His remittances paid $84.44. The gap was $12.51 on every single session.

What should you do when a payer is underpaying you?

Once you can see it, you stop guessing and start deciding, because now you have data instead of a feeling. A payer that pays below its own contract has to earn its place on your panel again, and you have three real options in front of you.


You can renegotiate, bringing the comparison to the payer and asking, in writing, for the rate you both signed for. You can reposition, keeping the payer on your panel while you steer new clients toward the payers that honor their contracts. Or you can exit the panel altogether, and you may find, as more than one owner has, that dropping a payer frees your schedule and earns you more than staying ever did.


What you cannot do is decide on a hunch. The numbers are the decision, which is the entire point of measuring them in the first place.


How long can you wait before the money is gone?

Not long, because time is the one ingredient that turns a fixable problem into a permanent loss. Recovery runs through appeal windows and timely filing limits, and those doors close a little more every week while the underpayment keeps repeating underneath them.


Wait three months and you have probably lost a lot of money. Wait six months and the loss can climb into the tens of thousands of dollars. Wait a full year and you can be staring at hundreds of thousands, gone, most of it unrecoverable. Owners walk away from money they already earned simply because nobody knew it was sitting there, and that is a tragedy, because the fix takes an afternoon. Put the review on your calendar and keep it there. Every 90 days, pull the last 90 days of payments and run the comparison again.


How do you stop underpayments before claims go out?

You stop it by building a system that catches the gap at the front end, before the claim ever leaves your office. Underpayment is a systems problem, not a people problem. It does not belong to your biller alone or your front desk alone, and the moment you make it one person's burden, it slips back into the walls.


Build these four things:

  • A checklist of what each payer should pay for your top codes

  • A flag that fires when a payment posts below the contracted rate

  • A process for gathering the evidence an appeal needs

  • A dashboard that shows a payer drifting before the drift becomes a pattern

Then train your team to run it. Teach your people what a correct payment looks like, down to the dollar, and they will spot a wrong one the day it posts. Measure it and you protect what you earned. Ignore it and you fund the payer's discount out of your own pocket.


Your three options with an underpaying payer



Option

What it takes

What you gain

The risk

Renegotiate

Your rate comparison and a written request

The contract rate you signed for

The payer stalls or says no

Reposition

Steering new clients to stronger payers

Better mix over time

Slow. The old payer still pays short

Exit the panel

Notice to the payer and a plan for current clients

Your full rate on every session you keep

A short-term dip in client volume

Key takeaways

  • Paid is not the same as paid correctly. The gap hides inside claims that show as paid.

  • Start measuring. Five payers and ten codes, set against your contracted rates.

  • Ten codes carry about 80% of your billing, so a drifted payer shows up fast.

  • An underpaying payer leaves you three options. Renegotiate, reposition, or exit.

  • Recovery windows close, so review the last 90 days of payments every 90 days.

  • Build the system and train your team, and the gap gets caught at the front end.


Frequently asked questions

Is underpayment the same as a denial?

No, and the difference matters. A denial pays you nothing and demands a response, so it gets one. An underpayment pays you less than your contract rate and demands nothing at all, and that silence is exactly why it can run for a year without anyone noticing.


How often should you check your contracted rates?

Every 90 days works. Pull the last 90 days of payments from your top payers and set them against the rates in your current contracts, and any drift shows up while it is still small enough to fix.


What if you do not know your contracted rates?

Call the payer and ask for them. A rate you cannot see cannot protect you, and a payer that will not tell you your own rate has already told you something worth knowing.


Can you recover money from old underpayments?

Yes, as long as you are still inside the appeal and timely filing windows. The older an underpayment gets, the harder it is to pull back, which is why the 90-day review matters. It keeps your money within reach.


Start today

You were trained to take care of your patients, not your billing, and that is perfectly fine. But money you already earned should never sit unclaimed just because nobody thought to look. Start today. Pick your biggest payer, run the comparison over a cup of coffee, and see what has been hiding in your own numbers.


Hear the full conversation in Episode 73 of The Claim Game, published November 16, 2026. If you want the system that catches this before the claim ever goes out, that is what we build in Billing Training.


Comments


Follow Us
  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • LinkedIn
From solo therapists to group practices, we provide scalable billing solutions for mental health professionals

Sign up to receive email updates from Practice Solutions!

Manage your practice with confidence by staying in the know on industry updates, excellent billing resources, and best practices

COMPLIANCE

Practice Solutions, LLC recognizes that providers seek to ensure that our organization is fully in compliance with the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). Our goal is to protect the privacy and security of individually identifiable health information and our client’s ability to use our services.
 

Practice Solutions, LLC, its software vendor and electronic clearinghouse are in compliance with all legislative and regulatory developments that are directly proportional to our customers’ business needs. Practice Solutions, LLC signs a trading partner agreement with all its vendors and its statement of compliance is outlined in the “Billing Services Agreement: Compliance Addendum” or “Business Associate Agreement”, which we provide to all our clients.

© 2025 by Practice Solutions. Powered by GoZoek.com

bottom of page